Since I started lurking around this site I've noticed every few months that a recurring debate will take place. The big question is "Should I glue my stick-through neck directly to the soundboard/lid or should there be a gap?"
Let's quickly recap the basic stances on each side of the debate:
- There should be a gap between the neck and lid to allow for better reverberation/sustain/tone/etc. from the strings though the bridge through the board and into your ears.
- The rebuttal to this is usually: it makes no difference to the sound/tone of the guitar; the pressure of the strings on the bridge can cause the soundboard to warp; weakens overall structure.
I'm sure there are other points that I'm missing but that's not really the point of this post. I think both arguments have merit and i dont want to make any concrete judgements on proper technique when I'm still figuring out what does and doesn't work for me. My rule if I'm unsure is try both and find out what I like better. There is usually a reason why both options exist. But..there might be a third option here. A sort of middle ground build that might make both camps happy.
I was pondering another foreseeable problem on a future build and I had an idea pop into my head. What if, instead of completely cutting away all of the material to leave a gap, there is a channel cut through the majority of the neck material leaving two braces on either side.
This could be done fairly easily with a hole saw and a jig saw. I would leave about 1/4" on each side. The line along the side is another idea I had to possibly cut away even more material. It would look kind of like a arched bridge. I think doing it this way would give plenty of support for the bridge yet allow the soundboard to vibrate freely. There's just as much or more bracing stuck to the top of an acoustic guitar, so I don't see how it could interfere with tonal quality.
What do you think of this for option 3? Has anyone tried something like this before? I think I'll give it a shot once I'm back in the shop making saw dust again.
Also, I'm not trying to open the old debate up again, but if you must voice an opinion about it, go ahead. I'm not the boss of you.
Nathan
Tags:
Interesting idea! My engineer side says the center slot will have no to very little effect, the board will remain fairly static, but that is armchair engineering with nothing but my gut behind it. The line along the side is more promising, basically you are making something like bracing now. It should act like bracing but at 1/4" thick it is probably still way more than what is under an acoustic. I'd say go for it and suggest making the box so you could open it and continue to relieve material and see what happens. Also the board should be tight to the lid so it doesn't buzz/vibrate.
Love the idea, like a "strum stick" it has thickness perpendicular to the soundboard to keep the neck from curving forward and turning the git into an archery bow, but opens up more of the resonant cavity and reduces the solid mass impeding the soundboard.
I would NOT do the cut from the side, the thinner the neck parallel to the soundboard, the more likely it will curve up under the string tension and give you a git that looks like it was designed by Salvador Dahli.
HOWEVER you might be able to take a forstner bit and drill a few holes sideways through the neck like Adam Savage's axe handle from the mythbuster's zombie special and get a similar effect...
He has all sorts of cool stuff. Google his One Day Builds. The dude's building skills amaze me. His shop is pretty awesome too.
The only way to really settle this is if you build two necks. One with your cutout and one without. Then switch them out so you use the same box, stings, piezo etc.
In the end, you should have a playable guitar (and maybe a piece of nice fire wood).
I think most of us would like to hear your results.
Thanks for the feedback so far. I'm honestly surprised that there isn't already an example of this already built.
I do like the idea of drilling out holes in the side of the channel instead of taking a big chunk out. It will be much stronger that way for sure.
I have a feeling it will do very little to change the sound but I will definitely try it out. Like I mentioned before, I'm stuck in my house until April so if anybody feels like they want to try it out before then please go for it and let us know how it turned out. My winters seem to have turned into 5 month sessions of planning and pondering while I wait for the sub-zero temperatures to leave. Maybe dealing with the winter building blues needs to be a topic another post...
Winter blues is here is Michigan too, although usually not five months! I can get into the garage and keep warm enough, but anything that makes significant sawdust is outside, and my hands can't take all the cold tools and surfaces for to long or they stiffen up, so I do work in short sessions when I can. Maybe look into building an amp, learn to solder, wire and such. And play more! I say that, but I have 2 or 3 cbg's cued up and a couple more rolling in my head as well.
I have been playing more. On vey morose days I like to play sad slow licks, but mostly I've been playing my ukelele. It's pretty hard to feel bummed out strumming that guy.
UPDATE: I'm well underway on the experiment and ready to glue the necks into their boxes.
I've attempted to keep everything as identical as possible. The 2 necks were cut from the same piece of maple as well as the fingerboards. I even resawed them from the same piece so they are kind of book matched. Same Punch cigar boxes obviously.
There was an incident with my router tearing out a chunk of the fretboard on one of them so that guy is 3mm thinner than the other. My slot worked out ok but I had to hand saw it as my scroll saw is broken at the moment. The cut got a little wonky on me but shouldn't effect the results of the experiment.
These CBGs are also prototypes for an "economy" model for my builds. Simplified fret markers, simpler headstock, 3 stringer and a piezo pickup. Here is where I need some input. I'm personally not a big fan of piezos but I got some cheap-o pre-wired to jack discs and I'm going to use them for these "cheap" builds. For the sake of the experiment, how should I mount them for the most consistent result. I can't really sandwich between the neck and top. Is the best way for these to do the under the bridge technique? I was going to the offcuts from the fretboards, cut a dado for the corian bridge and then make a little recess for the disc and glue it in with silicone.
Any other suggestions or go ahead with the under-bridge style?
I have done this with a dog bowl reso. Sounds amazing.
Started by BrianQ. in Performances, How to Play, Lessons, Concerts on Tuesday. 0 Replies 2 Likes
Started by J. D. Woods in Performances, How to Play, Lessons, Concerts. Last reply by Southern Ray on Friday. 8 Replies 1 Like
Started by Southern Ray in Other stuff - off topic, fun stuff, whatever. Last reply by Southern Ray Apr 26. 6 Replies 0 Likes
Started by J. D. Woods in Performances, How to Play, Lessons, Concerts. Last reply by BrianQ. Apr 25. 4 Replies 0 Likes
Started by Rich Butters in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Crazed Fandango Apr 22. 4 Replies 0 Likes
Started by Nomad Jack in Performances, How to Play, Lessons, Concerts. Last reply by J. D. Woods Apr 17. 7 Replies 2 Likes
Started by Moritz Voegeli in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Southern Ray Apr 14. 6 Replies 2 Likes
Started by Timothy Hunter in Other stuff - off topic, fun stuff, whatever. Last reply by Timothy Hunter Apr 10. 14 Replies 3 Likes
Started by Tom T in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Southern Ray Apr 9. 9 Replies 0 Likes
Started by Southern Ray in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Southern Ray Apr 4. 7 Replies 1 Like
Started by Timothy Hunter in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Southern Ray Mar 27. 1 Reply 2 Likes
Started by Taffy Evans in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Southern Ray Mar 10. 1 Reply 3 Likes
Started by Cigar Box Nation in Feature Articles. Last reply by BrianQ. Mar 9. 4 Replies 3 Likes
Started by Ghostbuttons in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Timothy Hunter Mar 9. 5 Replies 1 Like
Started by Justin Stanchfield in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Taffy Evans Mar 8. 6 Replies 0 Likes
Started by Ken I in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Brian partington Mar 8. 8 Replies 0 Likes
Started by Southern Ray in Cool gear discussion - that's not cigar box related. Last reply by Southern Ray Mar 6. 5 Replies 0 Likes
Started by Taffy Evans in Other stuff - off topic, fun stuff, whatever. Last reply by Taffy Evans Mar 5. 4 Replies 2 Likes
Started by Justin Stanchfield in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Carl Floyd Mar 1. 15 Replies 0 Likes
Started by Joe in Performances, How to Play, Lessons, Concerts. Last reply by Carl Floyd Feb 29. 13 Replies 0 Likes
Posted by Vlad on March 31, 2024 at 11:48pm 0 Comments 1 Like
Posted by Vlad on March 6, 2024 at 2:32am 5 Comments 2 Likes
Posted by billy jones bluez on February 28, 2024 at 2:09pm 0 Comments 0 Likes
Posted by billy jones bluez on February 17, 2024 at 11:00pm 0 Comments 0 Likes
Posted by Vlad on February 11, 2024 at 1:06am 1 Comment 1 Like
May 11, 2024 from 11am to 8pm – Speakeasy Grill
0 Comments 0 LikesMay 30, 2024 from 6:30pm to 10pm – The Casual Pint of Huntsville
0 Comments 0 Likes© 2024 Created by Ben "C. B. Gitty" Baker. Powered by
Cigar Box Nation is presented by C. B. Gitty Crafter Supply, your one-stop-shop for Cigar Box Guitar parts and accessories!