I am currently working on my 1st CBG after discovering this website, and having a blast thanks to you all!

I am building an acoustic (for now at least) 1 string, broomstick type fretless unit to be played with a slide...I am not a musician, just looking to have fun on this 1st build and be able to play around with it.  

On the forums I read about the std. 24.5 - 25.5" scale length, but would like to make mine a bit longer....say 27-29". The 1st of several reasons is that I cut my round neck hole just below the box lid bottom in order to have more resonance from the box...of course, after hours of pouring thru the forums I see I should have squared off the "internal" section of the neck going thru the box in order to raise the neck level w/the box for easier playing/string height. Noobie mistake # 1.

 

2nd, based on my "fretboard" height in relation to the box, I am worried that if I use a 25.5" scale length I will have a very limited area on the neck to play before the strings hit the top edge of the box where it meets the neck.

3rd, I would like the bridge to rest in an aesthetically pleasing and comfortable location on the box if possible. This pic shows approx. where I'd like to place the bridge.

 

 

I've read that a tall string height is not a problem using a slide, so I was hoping to use a longer scale with a tall enough bridge & nut setup to allow clearance for my neck issue.

 

 

Please let me know if you would suggest I make the 25.5" work, or what issues I might run into if I go with a longer length....or any other problems you see in my photos.

 

Thanks in advance, Joe.

Views: 417

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

If you are not concerned with tuning the string to any specific pitch (note), the scale length does not matter at all. A guitar has a standard scale length of about 25". Standard guitar strings are gauged so they come to the correct pitch utilizing this scale length. The longer the scale, the lower the note. This means the string will be heavier too. At about 27" you are going into the baritone guitar range. I hope this information helps. Enjoy your build, Keni Lee      

Thanks for the reply Keni Lee. When you say going into the baritone range, couldn't I just pick a different (higher pitch) string from a set in order to compensate & get back to a similar tone as a 25" scale would have produced or will the difference be too great to accomplish this way? Sorry for my lack of musical knowledge...I appreciate your help very much!  Joe

Experiment. String tension and tone is important. If the string tension is too loose, the vibrational energy will be weak and not vibrate the box. If the string tension is too tight, it locks up the instrument and the box does not vibrate either. Thin strings create less engergy than heavier strings. This is what happens when you go away from a standard. Uncharted space. Trying different strings and tunings is the best way to actual hear the sound. You are building a prototype, not a final model. It is trial by error around here. Enjoy.   

Thanks again for your help Keni!

The only real consideration is will the string reach, especially cheaper ones don't give you much spare length
I haven't tried this before, but I would consider placing the bridge on the neck side of the box rather than the tail. Or those Punch boxes are relatively easy to obtain....at least around me. Might be worth a redo since you are just starting out.

Good luck and have fun!

Thanks for all your input. Strings are long enough so I think I'm going to build it 1st without glueing & go from there.

 

 

RSS

The Essential Pages

New to Cigar Box Nation?How to Play Cigar Box GuitarsFree Plans & How to Build Cigar Box GuitarsCigar Box Guitar Building BasicsCigar Box Guitar Parts Store

Site Sponsor

Recommended Links & Resources

Forum

Folk Outsider, 3-String Stephen LIVE at Gitty's

Started by Shane Speal shanespeal.com in Feature Articles. Last reply by Jim Morris yesterday. 3 Replies

Thin a top

Started by Mark Werner in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Mark Werner yesterday. 23 Replies

Threw the PICK away

Started by Jeff 'Bones' Reilly in Performances, How to Play, Lessons, Concerts. Last reply by Dustin Aurand on Monday. 9 Replies

Latest Activity

James O Lunsford commented on James O Lunsford's video
Thumbnail

Blues Camping On My Back Porch

"Thanks Derek It's easy for Me to write Lyrics to a good Backing track and fun to do sometime…"
7 minutes ago
James O Lunsford commented on Derek Rose's video
10 minutes ago
James O Lunsford liked Derek Rose's video
11 minutes ago
James O Lunsford replied to Snuffy Smith's discussion How do you transfer your CBG playing to digital files?
"Try this software Mix Pad you can download it here it's free and very…"
14 minutes ago
Snuffy Smith replied to Snuffy Smith's discussion How do you transfer your CBG playing to digital files?
"Yeah, I'm completely in the dark on all of this technology. I work on a Mac, but not with…"
15 minutes ago
Primitive Acoustics replied to Snuffy Smith's discussion How do you transfer your CBG playing to digital files?
"Those interfaces look ok. The iRig series gets good reviews, but I have no experience with them.…"
39 minutes ago
Danny Joe posted photos
1 hour ago
the anonymous pick left a comment for Kevin Wiley
"welcome . "
1 hour ago
Nigel McTrustry commented on Nigel McTrustry's video
1 hour ago
43rd Shamrock commented on 43rd Shamrock's photo
Thumbnail

Dog bowl resonator

"I was at the local Dollar Tree store the other day to pick up a jug of ice tea and some doggie…"
1 hour ago
43rd Shamrock commented on 43rd Shamrock's photo
Thumbnail

Dog bowl resonator

"Uncle John.... the "Not Laser cut" comment is my "dig" on trying to keep these…"
1 hour ago
the anonymous pick commented on Derek Rose's video
1 hour ago

Music

Loading…

© 2017   Created by Ben "C. B. Gitty" Baker.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service