Hi ! I would really like to know what cigar box brands I should try to get my hands on to get a good cbg,so I wonder what boxes are the "most prefered" among the modern boxes and also among older ones?I do understand this probably is a matter of what each one likes,but I guess there must be some guidelines to go on,and personal favorites for everyone.I am only at my second build so I do not have to mush to compare with,but I prefer my Gran Corona box compared to my Ramon Alones (wraped box).It was a lot easier working with the Gran Corona,the wood seemed to be better than in the Ramon alones box,I´m not sure,but I guess the "wraped boxes" are made of wood with less quality.
Some general guidlines I've learned, with a heavy dose of personal opinion:
Bigger boxes will give you more volume acoustically.
Deeper boxes will give you more bass.
Wood resonates better than Masonite or pressboard (what's usually under the paper labels on newer boxes)
Thin wood resonates better than thick wood.
Solid wood resonates better than plywood.
My personal favorites in no particular order are Cohiba Toros, Churchills and Robustos: Padron Series 1926, Maduros, and Exclusivos; Graycliffs (very thin plywood tops); La Aurora Preferidos; Macanudo Gold Label Shakespeares and Tudors; Punch; or anything that catches my eye at the tobacconist's that day.
None of the above really matters, there are no rules, find a box you like and build what you want. Now go forth and multiply!
Thanks a lot Habanera Hal! I find your guideline very usefull,with this a builder can choice box for the specific sound he or she is after in each build!That´s great!This is a good help,thanks! By the way...if you had to chose only one box (brand) to build all your cbg´s in the future,what box would you go for then?And If you have a favourite amongst the ones you have built,what box did you use? :-)
You're welcome, Tor! That's what we're all here for. That's a tough question to answer, as I try to never build two CBGs alike! I guess my absolute favorite for right now as a "standard" box would be the Cohiba "Red Dot" Robustos. They are solid wood (no plywood), come with a nice clean finsh, and I like the proportions when building a thin (1-1/2" wide) 3-string neck. I just finished this one a little while back and I have another one in black and believe they also come in a white finish:
But again, it's all personal taste. This is the one on my workbench right now, an Artesanos de Obelisco:
Sometimes it's just the rarity of the box or the vibes you feel coming from it when you hold it. LOL.
Thanks for giving a satisfacting answer to an (almost) impossible question,Habanera Hal! The Cohiba "Red Dot" Robustos looks great,the things that catched my eye especially at that one is the cool shape of the head,I also like the thin bridge,discret,not "disturbing" the look of the box,yeah,I understand you got an eye for proportions! The other one with the "great vibes :-)",the Artesano de Obelisco,Is a beautiful piece,the binding really lifted that box up many levels!The Rising moon up the neck looks great to! Thanks a lot for sharing(bouth experienced knowledge and pictures)!