Hi,

 

I am aware that to tune a six string as the scale gets shorter the strings either have to be tuned to a higher pitch or the strings need to get fatter.  I managed to tune my uke to DGBE by using hard tension classical strings from 2 strings over (low E used for D, A for the G, D for the B and G for the highE) and this works well on the 14 inch scale.

 

I recently picked up a cymbala/lap harp off ebay which uses 40 gauge piano wire and was thinking of trying to make a short scale fretted travel guitar with 6 strings with as small a scale as possible using piano wire - thickest I can easily get is .051 diameter (size23).

Available sizes are  

Available diameter sizes of wires:-

  • Size  00        .008
  • Size  0          .009
  • Size  1          .010
  • Size  3          .012
  • Size  5          .014
  • Size  6          .016
  • Size  7          .018
  • Size  8          .020
  • Size  9          .022
  • Size  10        .024
  • Size  11        .026
  • Size  12        .028
  • Size  12.5     .029
  • Size  13        .030
  • Size  13.5     .031
  • Size  14        .032
  • Size  14.5     .033
  • Size  15        .034
  • Size  15.5     .035
  • Size  16        .036
  • Size  16.5     .037
  • Size  17        .038
  • Size  17.5     .039
  • Size  18        .040
  • Size  18.5     .041
  • Size  19        .042
  • Size  19.5     .043
  • Size  20        .044
  • Size  20.5     .045
  • Size  21        .046
  • Size  22        .048
  • Size  23        .051

Like the cymbala I was thinking of using 1 gauge of wire to tune for 2 strings (tuning peg upto wrap around pin and back to other tuning peg).  I was going to stick to standard guitar tuning EADGBE and was hoping somebody out there could give me an idea of how short a scale I can use?

 

Regards,

David

You need to be a member of Cigar Box Nation to add comments!

Join Cigar Box Nation

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Don:
    Thanks for posting this. I've been kicking around a concept for a solid bodied, travel sized, tenor ukulele for a while now. My idea is very simular to this, but with a 17" scale and a total instrument length of 20". My goal is to also incorporate an onboard headphone amp with eq and a compressor. The challenge is figuring out where to fit everything.

    Don Thompson said:
  • The shortest I've built a guitar for standard tuning is 21 inch scale, and this needs pretty heavy strings. Any shorter than this and the string gauges get very heavy - there's an optimium tension for strings, and if you are well under this you may run into intonation problems. Making a short scale guitar and tuning it higher (as if using a capo) isn't too much of a problem.

    Using piano wire seems like a bad idea - why use piano wire? Guitar strings are available in a wide range of gauges and they are cheap. Plain piano wire will be awful to string up with, especially anything over a 025 gauge, as it just won't want to bend round the machineheads and conform to the bridge (a wound string of the same gauge will have a much skinnier core).
  • A very intersting/imformative thread. I am finding you cant put guitar strings on small scaled CBG's the guitar strings are not made for short scales, the higher/thinner the string the tighter it has to be to produce the same note and them the tight string overpowers the rest in voluem. I guess the uke strings are made for the shorter scale Cheers Ron.
  • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y1BiPbxX1YU&feature=related
    David, This vid was the inspiration for my short scale instruments. Awesome homemade guitar. Notice the guitar is capoed at the fifth fret as I described earlier on? I thought well heck, just shorten the scale then. Guitars like the Traveler are trying to be as short as possible hence the body mounted tuners.
  • Thank you for sharing this Don - it is the first time I have seen a uke like this!.
    It puts the Gakken "miniguitar" to shame. I have seen a few larger sized travel guitars with a similar design and have wondered why they run the strings around a bar and have the tuners part way up the body? Is it simply to save a couple of inches that the machineheads would add or does the extra bit of string mean less string tension overall?


    Don Thompson said:
  • Ha, Found a picture of of another acoustic ukitar I built. Notice how steep the saddle slant is? Needed for intonation as the shorter the scale the more critical fret placement and bridge placement becomes. Plenty of room for inovation in building. Inovation? Check out my pop bottle ukulele. Both bottles have tire valve stems and are blown up with air. Kind of a banjo uke sound. I know I've never seen anything like it.
    David, before I forget, I measured a regular guitar neck at the fifth fret and made that my nut width for a wider fingerboard. Pretty cool, huh?

    acoustic ukitar.jpg

    bottleuke001.jpg

  • A good point well made Don.
  • How anyone can call that electric ukulele a guitar is beyound me. But people misname things all the time. bleh.......Good luck building a 16" scale guitar using only three gauges of strings. One string will be floppy the next very taunt. Not the kind of guitar I'd be interested in playing. Difficult to play, why? Save a couple of bucks? Guitar strings sets are designed to have close to the same "feel" sheesh, why mess with centuries of evolution of the musical instrument. I'm all for inovation but to me playability comes first. Don


    David Lloyd said:
    Thank you Diane for the link to the strothers.com - I have had a play around with it.

    ...And a big thank you to Don for the helpful information.

    What set me off on the idea of a ultra small scaled guitar was a video Roosterman posted a while ago of a mini 4 string guitar http://www.cigarboxnation.com/video/the-totally-awesome-mini made by Gakken http://www.japantrendshop.com/gakken-mini-electric-guitar-p-834.htm...
    so I was thinking about what is actually possible with regards to playable size (basically with a fretboard below 14inches the frets get too close together for me to play easily) and thickness of string needed for the smaller scale. It looks like to get the full 6 strings EADGBE a 16inch scale may be a more workable option.

    Don - am I right in thinking the cymbala idea fretted doesn't work because the strings are too rigid to fret easily and/or at such a small scale you would get major intonation problems?

    The idea behind piano wire was a really cheap material to work with - although looking at the available guitar string sets with nice fat strings I realise there is cheap and then there is fit for purpose :O) I must admit though I like the idea on the cymbala where one string is used to tune to 2 different notes using a zither pin-string anchor-zither pin arrangement.

    Regards,
    David
  • Hi Swampapple,

    There is a recent post here where someone had a similar problem http://www.cigarboxnation.com/forum/topics/how-to-get-more-sustain which might give some ideas. If this is no help you might be better adding a new post to the forum giving more information - strings used, type of box, material used for nut and bridge and photos - everyone loves photos. A new thread would open the discussion up to everyone as those with no interest in small scale instuments are likely to read it here.

    Regards,
    David


    swampapple slim said:
    i have a 19 in 3 string sounds dead any sugestions?
This reply was deleted.