I like the insides of the picture that heads this forum. It seems that a real attempt has been made to get the best sound out of his box (that suits him!)

I was wondering if the guitar theory of bars and bracing really applies to CBGs?

Regarding bracing, then if we are to have more than 4 strings or use high tension strings then there does appear to be a need to construct bracing to keep the neck and the box in line and prevent warping.

Acoustic bars, depending on the thickness of the sound board wood, might not do much to "improve" the sound?
The same with the thin supporting bars that are traditionally put around the guitar rose sound hole. They are clearly needed for a wide thin sound board, but I doubt if of value to a cigar box.

Similarly the fan and cross bars carefully placed to accentuate the required sound for the guitar, I cant think that they will really change the sound produced except to the most discerning ear.

What do you think?

Views: 513

Replies to This Discussion

vanity....vanity....putting sequines on a sow's ear doesn't make it a silk purse....

JMHO,

Wichita Sam
That's a good one! So putting an ear tag on a a silk purse likely doesn't make it a sow either?
On my guitars, I've found that I don't really need to do more than glue a strip of 1/4" red oak right under the bridge and line the sides of the box with 1/2" poplar (box lid is glued to this poplar frame). That's for an acoustic bridge. If I have something like a Gibson style bridge, I change the 1/4" strip to about 1/2". The lid (soundboard) is so small in our case that just a little bit of extra reinforcement around the sides is enough to bear the load.

As far as keeping the neck in line with the box, yeah, if I'm using a standard six string neck I'll usually run about a 3/4" inch piece of oak down the center of the body and either glue or bolt my neck to that. That's good enough to get me what I need in all cases.

I've never done it before and I tend more towards electric instruments anyway, but I have to imagine that you're not getting a whole lot of return on your investment of traditional bars and braces. Yeah it keeps the box more supple and light and preserves its ability to resonate but really, we're only talking about an 8 X 6.5 X 1.5 box here. You're never going to get this thing to sound like a classical Spanish guitar. An acoustic CBG sounds thin and tinny. Moreover, that's what they're supposed to sound like. That's that Delta Blues sound everyone keeps plugging. If you want it to sound like a dreadnought, get yourself a bending iron and make a dreadnought.
I have to say that in building a CBG there is no way that I "want" it to sound sweet. I use the term "twangy blues guitar" is what I want.

However the acoustics do interest me and I might try and make a "sweet psaltery-like" CBG one day!! :)

It is probably called a CB Dulcimer?????

Perhaps we should encase a CB into the body of a classical guitar and see how that sounds? !!!!!
I have tried all kinds of bracing to improve box stability, and to see what sound comes out. I made a six string dulci-mandolin with very thin all wood box, with an X brace, and it sounded very good. I also put an X brace on the bottom with a "sound post" on the bass string side. I was surprised at the nice tone. The box was Cedar. I put kerfing along the inside edges to strengthen the box, as it had six strings with lots of tension, tuned in the mandolin range. I took it to a jam and sold it. That was the best sounding CB mando to date. I now make them with the stick on the top, like a traditional dulcimer.
hey richard, can you throw up a picture of something similar? so those of us less experienced can see and understand what exactly you did.

Richard Sanabia said:
I have tried all kinds of bracing to improve box stability, and to see what sound comes out. I made a six string dulci-mandolin with very thin all wood box, with an X brace, and it sounded very good. I also put an X brace on the bottom with a "sound post" on the bass string side. I was surprised at the nice tone. The box was Cedar. I put kerfing along the inside edges to strengthen the box, as it had six strings with lots of tension, tuned in the mandolin range. I took it to a jam and sold it. That was the best sounding CB mando to date. I now make them with the stick on the top, like a traditional dulcimer.
Seems to me that for typical thru-neck CBGs with 3 or 4 strings there really isn't a need for any bracing. I haven't built an instrument with more strings than that yet so I can only theorise about what the situation would be with a 6-string guitar or something like a mandolin.

One significant factor in the question of bracing is the ratio of a soundboard's width to its thickness. Traditional guitar soundboards need bracing to stop them bowing because they're made of thin wood and they span a considerable width (even across the narrowest part of some guitar bodies and certainly across the part where the bridge sits). Most cigar boxes and biscuit tins are much smaller than the body of an average guitar - so the soundboard (typically the box lid) is spanning a much shorter width. And the cigar box lids I've encountered are a bit thicker than a guitar soundboard. So simple engineering says you already have a much more rigid soundboard, and so you're less likely to need bracing. The idea that bracing contributes to sound is a bit of a red herring - it's certainly important to design bracing so that it doesn't mess up the sound of an instrument, but the primary reason for bracing is surely to provide strength rather than to improve sound.

I've just built a 3-string CBG strung and tuned like Seasick Steve's guitar (ie. G-G-B using a low E-string tuned up 3 semitones, a D-string tuned up 5-semitones and a G-string tuned up 4-semitones) - that's a reasonably heavy load but there's no sign of even the slightest bow in either the box or the neck (which has no trussrod).

Probably silly to resurrect this thread (on nearly its 5-year anniversary :) )
but...

It occurs to me that one could achieve a thinner (and presumably higher resonance) CB soundboard if, rather than adding braces, one subtracted material (thickness) with a router and the material that you LEFT became (in effect) the bracing. I think this idea would work best if the lid is solid wood (not plywood). Would be interesting to compare two identically constructed CBGs with this "router reveal" of bracing being the only difference.

RSS

The Essential Pages

New to Cigar Box Nation?How to Play Cigar Box GuitarsFree Plans & How to Build Cigar Box GuitarsCigar Box Guitar Building BasicsCigar Box Guitar Parts Store

Site Sponsor


Recommended Links & Resources

Discussion Forum

An idea that I haven't seen - any thoughts?

Started by Habanera Hal. Last reply by Fomhorach 8 hours ago. 12 Replies

A brand new resonator

Started by Mario Poggio. Last reply by Philip Hale 8 hours ago. 9 Replies

Measuring wood ( and/or box) resonances - cheaply

Started by Darren Addy. Last reply by Fomhorach 18 hours ago. 6 Replies

Signing your work

Started by Chuck Dubman. Last reply by G.S. Monroe Dec 21, 2015. 17 Replies

Braces and bars.

Started by Brian Lemin. Last reply by Monterey Mar 20, 2015. 8 Replies

Nonadjustable truss rod

Started by Scott W. Last reply by Scott W Jul 17, 2014. 9 Replies

Builders tricks

Started by Lee Martin. Last reply by Wichita Sam Apr 3, 2014. 4 Replies

Making a brass tailpiece

Started by Tim Mac. Last reply by Better Trees Jan 16, 2014. 3 Replies

Resonator cone and coverplate

Started by Keith Weser. Last reply by Mario Poggio Nov 30, 2013. 9 Replies

Neck dovetail

Started by Jillian Holladay. Last reply by Jillian Holladay Jul 23, 2013. 12 Replies

Neck Angle

Started by Wayne Bigler. Last reply by Wayne Bigler Jul 12, 2013. 5 Replies

"Testing" a box for bridge placement

Started by Roadkill a.k.a. John Maw. Last reply by Mark Bliss Jul 11, 2013. 163 Replies

Bridge attachment comparison.

Started by MichaelS Country Boy Guitars. Last reply by StarrCBGs(Donovan) Jul 10, 2013. 19 Replies

fret board material

Started by Sam Fontenot. Last reply by StarrCBGs(Donovan) Jul 10, 2013. 17 Replies

fret buzz

Started by Craig Cox. Last reply by StarrCBGs(Donovan) Jul 10, 2013. 2 Replies

Soundhole sizing and design

Started by Habanera Hal. Last reply by Michael Recchione May 15, 2013. 20 Replies

My current work in progress - Romeo

Started by James Haney. Last reply by Michael Glenn Dec 8, 2011. 7 Replies

Removeable frets?!!

Started by Mark Bliss. Last reply by Mark Bliss Nov 7, 2011. 4 Replies

How to calculate and implement a fanned fretboard?

Started by Rand Moore. Last reply by Rand Moore Aug 13, 2011. 7 Replies

Dot size

Started by Chuck Dubman. Last reply by Penny Nelson Jul 10, 2011. 6 Replies

Blog Posts

soundboard wood

Posted by jeff weins on April 29, 2016 at 4:50pm 3 Comments

Vibro-Uke

Posted by Primitive Acoustics on April 28, 2016 at 1:30pm 11 Comments

Zenstrument #5.

Posted by Murdoc_420 on April 28, 2016 at 12:06am 3 Comments

The Latest Version

Posted by Hal Robertson on April 22, 2016 at 9:19am 6 Comments

I think I messed up

Posted by Andrew Corl on April 21, 2016 at 12:38pm 6 Comments

Latest Activity

Jittery Jay posted a discussion

What's your day job?

I'm sure there are a bunch of you folks that have a musical foundation in your occupation, but for…See More
6 minutes ago
Maddog commented on SlowHound's video
11 minutes ago
the anonymous pick commented on the anonymous pick's video
Thumbnail

SOMETHING'S STIRRING AT SWAMP WITCH GUITARS

"early-bird   may get the worm  ...  but  the  2nd mouse  gets the…"
13 minutes ago
Maddog commented on Dave Lynas's video
19 minutes ago
Maddog liked Dave Lynas's video
22 minutes ago
BP - RabidSalad - posted a discussion

Whats your excuse.

 Oh man...  Its raining today and I had a lot of stuff to do outside today but now....   Well I'm…See More
26 minutes ago
Maddog commented on the anonymous pick's video
30 minutes ago
shane wagstaff commented on shane wagstaff's video
33 minutes ago
Maddog liked ron carlson's photo
42 minutes ago
Maddog commented on ron carlson's photo
Thumbnail

Cinco De Mayo amp 2

"I'd say that year was well spent Ron! Turned out really nice Man! I've been meaning to…"
42 minutes ago
Maddog commented on Lapsteel washboard's photo
46 minutes ago
Maddog commented on Uncle John's photo
Thumbnail

Tin Can Annie

"I was able to see this at mid build on my last visit and I must say the end result is…"
50 minutes ago

Music

Loading…

© 2016   Created by Ben "C. B. Gitty" Baker.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service