What is everyones feelings on the use of open tuners? I've looked at allot of pics and almost everyone uses sealed tuners. Is their a reason for using the sealed ones? I was thinking of using open ones because I actually like the look of the gearing. Just wanted some thoughts on the subject.Thanks for reading.

Views: 149

Replies to This Discussion

Earl,

 

Sealed tuners have a reputation of being more stable under tension.  There's more mass to the body and the gearing is usually more precise.  But, a cheap sealed tuner can be worse than a good open tuner.  I've played the heck out of CBGs with open tuners and some of my custom clients ask for them to get that vintage look....  Here's where many go wrong with open tuners... they are subject to the backing plate bowing.  If the bow is outward (away from the guitar), this spreads the gears and makes everything loose.  I've seen poorly installed open tuners actually slip/skip gears...  If you pay attention to keeping everything square and tight, an open  back tuner will work just fine.

 

the best,

 

Wichita Sam

Thanks for the insight.I was wondering why you didn't see many open tuners.I honestly like the look of the open tuner.I think seeing the gearing has a neat look.I certainly don't want to have trouble with the tuners.Is their an open tuner that you would recommend? I am not opposed to closed tuners I just like the open tuner look.

Wichita Sam said:

Earl,

 

Sealed tuners have a reputation of being more stable under tension.  There's more mass to the body and the gearing is usually more precise.  But, a cheap sealed tuner can be worse than a good open tuner.  I've played the heck out of CBGs with open tuners and some of my custom clients ask for them to get that vintage look....  Here's where many go wrong with open tuners... they are subject to the backing plate bowing.  If the bow is outward (away from the guitar), this spreads the gears and makes everything loose.  I've seen poorly installed open tuners actually slip/skip gears...  If you pay attention to keeping everything square and tight, an open  back tuner will work just fine.

 

the best,

 

Wichita Sam

Any supplier's "economy tuners" usually work out well.  When you get them, just twist the stem... it ought to have some resistance, not loosey-goosey.  If there is wabble between the stem and the box, check to see if the screw attaching the gear to the post is loose.  If it is, tighen it up.  That ought to snug up the gears.  If it doesn't, its a bad tuner.... You can expect 3-5 in a hundred economy tuners to be unusable.  Most are just find.  Then just be careful during installation not to flex the backing plate and things will be fine......

 

Sam

Earl William Birth III said:

Thanks for the insight.I was wondering why you didn't see many open tuners.I honestly like the look of the open tuner.I think seeing the gearing has a neat look.I certainly don't want to have trouble with the tuners.Is their an open tuner that you would recommend? I am not opposed to closed tuners I just like the open tuner look.

Wichita Sam said:

Earl,

 

Sealed tuners have a reputation of being more stable under tension.  There's more mass to the body and the gearing is usually more precise.  But, a cheap sealed tuner can be worse than a good open tuner.  I've played the heck out of CBGs with open tuners and some of my custom clients ask for them to get that vintage look....  Here's where many go wrong with open tuners... they are subject to the backing plate bowing.  If the bow is outward (away from the guitar), this spreads the gears and makes everything loose.  I've seen poorly installed open tuners actually slip/skip gears...  If you pay attention to keeping everything square and tight, an open  back tuner will work just fine.

 

the best,

 

Wichita Sam

RSS

The Essential Pages

New to Cigar Box Nation?How to Play Cigar Box GuitarsFree Plans & How to Build Cigar Box GuitarsCigar Box Guitar Building BasicsCigar Box Guitar Parts Store

Site Sponsor

Recommended Links & Resources

Discussion Forum

Nails for frets?

Started by Mike. Last reply by Alan Robinson Aug 1. 8 Replies

Flea market finds

Started by Mike Jul 24. 0 Replies

Not just a lolly stick

Started by Wade Jan 2, 2015. 0 Replies

Save that box screw up!

Started by Wade. Last reply by Thomas "Duck" Petry Dec 4, 2014. 2 Replies

CB string height gauge

Started by Wade. Last reply by Wade Jul 9, 2014. 2 Replies

Recycled stuff

Started by Keith 66 Jun 11, 2014. 0 Replies

Free recycled Piezo pickups

Started by Wade. Last reply by Rob Brighton Jul 3, 2013. 19 Replies

Joining Lumber

Started by Where's Uranus?. Last reply by Mark Lindsay Jun 4, 2013. 8 Replies

Fretboard radius

Started by Wade. Last reply by rusty case Feb 11, 2013. 1 Reply

Free grounding foil

Started by Wade Feb 10, 2013. 0 Replies

Free Fret dot markers

Started by Wade. Last reply by Mark Lindsay Feb 3, 2013. 23 Replies

Recycled tonewood

Started by rusty case. Last reply by rusty case Nov 21, 2012. 13 Replies

Low $ substitute for banjo face?

Started by rusty case. Last reply by rusty case Nov 18, 2012. 6 Replies

Cheapo strings

Started by Karl G. Siewert. Last reply by rusty case Aug 27, 2012. 4 Replies

Hand saw.

Started by Wade. Last reply by rusty case Aug 27, 2012. 2 Replies

Tennis, anyone?

Started by Order99. Last reply by Order99 Aug 18, 2012. 4 Replies

1/2 Priced Nuts and Saddles

Started by Claude. Last reply by Order99 Apr 8, 2012. 10 Replies

Sources of bone for nuts/etc...

Started by BT Cohosh. Last reply by Karl G. Siewert Mar 15, 2012. 13 Replies

Cheap and easy bottle neck slide polisher

Started by Steve Becker. Last reply by Jeff Powers Jan 29, 2012. 7 Replies

Tuner preference

Started by Earl William Birth III. Last reply by Wichita Sam Mar 25, 2011. 3 Replies

Latest Activity

Korrigan commented on Korrigan's photo
Thumbnail

Mable

"Thanks guys"
3 minutes ago
Korrigan commented on Korrigan's photo
Thumbnail

Mable

"Ha! Originally the thick string didn't have a nut and the thick string's tuning shaft was…"
4 minutes ago
Bobb Negus updated their profile
6 minutes ago
Korrigan commented on Korrigan's photo
Thumbnail

Mable

"That's as low as it can go without adding a fingerboard but yeah, I don't want to mess up…"
19 minutes ago
Dave liked Korrigan's photo
35 minutes ago
Dave liked Randy S. Bretz's photo
35 minutes ago
Dave liked StarrCBGs(Donovan)'s photo
36 minutes ago
Dave liked Korrigan's photo
37 minutes ago
Slowpaw Steve T replied to Slowpaw Steve T's discussion CIGAR BOX NATION 2017 CHRISTMAS ALBUM SUBMISSIONS PAGE
"Sounds good!(-:"
58 minutes ago
Dave Lynas commented on Korrigan's photo
Thumbnail

Mable

"The tapered neck is killer!"
1 hour ago
Dave Lynas liked Korrigan's photo
1 hour ago
Dave Lynas commented on Korrigan's photo
Thumbnail

Mable

"Crazy man! Very rule breaking. I like it!"
1 hour ago

Events

Music

Loading…

© 2017   Created by Ben "C. B. Gitty" Baker.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service