What is the average size of the cigar box used for most 3 string guitars? I was at a cigar shop the other day and they just look small, but now I'm thinking they were probably ok. My dad has a few old box's that held 50 cigars, they look small too. I would use them except they are cardboard not wood. I realize anything goes with the CBG but I want it to look "right" : )

Views: 9293

Replies to This Discussion

There isn't one. Build with what you got. I will tell you that there are the palmitas/coronas sized boxes that are kinda small. May be great for diddly bows -- sorta, but I would go for something like this Arturo Fuente Chruchill box. Somewhere in that size range.

OH, but DO NOT pay too much. The price on ebay is about street price +/- $1. DO NOT pay $10 for a box unless you can't get them anywhere else. Also don't get cheap thin paper boxes like elProducto or White Owl. Crap like you would get in a convenience store.

-WY
I think that is about the size I was looking at, without the neck on it it didn't look right. My dad has since found me 2 wood vintage cigar box's for me, he was using them to store small parts for the last 40+ years, perfect!
Vintage in the classic sense.
Remember that on a 3 stringer you can narrow the neck to maybe 1 3/8", have good string spacing and help the box look more proportioned.... as far as sounding good, the "holy grail" of boxes, the Macanudo PortoFino Cafe only measures 7 1/2 X 8 1/2....

Sometimes, the best thing is to build what you got..... I've built on about everything that's come into my hands.... they all work (some better than others:-)

the best,
Wichita Sam
If your going to build electric I dont think it matters all that much what size you build.I build most all acoustic so I tend to attempt to stay 8 inches or longer.But, like Sam said, build what ya got and dont worry about it too much.
Decide what size you want to stick to and then measure any boxes your thinking about buying, then you wont have to guess if its the "right size"
why is the Macanudo PortoFino Cafe the holy grail of boxes? is it different wood/built different?


Wichita Sam said:
Remember that on a 3 stringer you can narrow the neck to maybe 1 3/8", have good string spacing and help the box look more proportioned.... as far as sounding good, the "holy grail" of boxes, the Macanudo PortoFino Cafe only measures 7 1/2 X 8 1/2....

Sometimes, the best thing is to build what you got..... I've built on about everything that's come into my hands.... they all work (some better than others:-)

the best,
Wichita Sam
I've since gotten 3 macanudo box's and her is my opinion. I think it is the plywood they use, and the size has some effect also. The plywood only has 3 plys and the outer 2 are very thin so there is not much glue to stiffen the wood and deaden it, when you tap on the top it has a nicer ring to it. Some box's have wood with 5 plys, that gives you 4 layers of glue plus the criss crossed grain of the plys I think makes a deader sound. Just my opinion though, and the macanudos I have are almost 3" deep. You can learn a lot in a few months!

Vini Machado said:
why is the Macanudo PortoFino Cafe the holy grail of boxes? is it different wood/built different?


Wichita Sam said:
Remember that on a 3 stringer you can narrow the neck to maybe 1 3/8", have good string spacing and help the box look more proportioned.... as far as sounding good, the "holy grail" of boxes, the Macanudo PortoFino Cafe only measures 7 1/2 X 8 1/2....

Sometimes, the best thing is to build what you got..... I've built on about everything that's come into my hands.... they all work (some better than others:-)

the best,
Wichita Sam
Its simply the best sounding box. Dunno why. Might be the dimensions or the wood. Mine I came across by accident and, in spite the fact I made it, it still sounds great.

-WY

Vini Machado said:
why is the Macanudo PortoFino Cafe the holy grail of boxes? is it different wood/built different?


Wichita Sam said:
Remember that on a 3 stringer you can narrow the neck to maybe 1 3/8", have good string spacing and help the box look more proportioned.... as far as sounding good, the "holy grail" of boxes, the Macanudo PortoFino Cafe only measures 7 1/2 X 8 1/2....

Sometimes, the best thing is to build what you got..... I've built on about everything that's come into my hands.... they all work (some better than others:-)

the best,
Wichita Sam
My first guitar was built on a box that measure 9 x 6.5 x 1.75 inches. That may be somewhat small but it worked. I have some bigger boxes that I am going to try next. They measure 12 x 7.25 x 2.25 inches. If possible, try to find one that has the finger jointed corners because they should be somewhat stronger. Stay away from cardboard, they might work for awhile but they are really too fragile. You can find any numer of good wood boxes on Ebay. Good luck. Bob
Robert,

I don't think your box was too small.... it's not the size (with in reason), it's want you do with it.... many of my smaller CBs end up as strummers.....

the best,

Sam

Robert Hynden said:
My first guitar was built on a box that measure 9 x 6.5 x 1.75 inches. That may be somewhat small but it worked. I have some bigger boxes that I am going to try next. They measure 12 x 7.25 x 2.25 inches. If possible, try to find one that has the finger jointed corners because they should be somewhat stronger. Stay away from cardboard, they might work for awhile but they are really too fragile. You can find any numer of good wood boxes on Ebay. Good luck. Bob

RSS

The Essential Pages

New to Cigar Box Nation?How to Play Cigar Box GuitarsFree Plans & How to Build Cigar Box GuitarsCigar Box Guitar Building BasicsCigar Box Guitar Parts Store

Site Sponsor

Recommended Links & Resources

Discussion Forum

Looking for inexpensive strings

Started by James Matthews. Last reply by James Matthews on Thursday. 13 Replies

Build 3

Started by Doug "Nomad" Farish. Last reply by Doug "Nomad" Farish Jun 17. 7 Replies

Tenor Uke, Banjo Fret Templates

Started by James Matthews. Last reply by James Matthews Jun 8. 4 Replies

An AWESOME FIND, and HELP!!

Started by Andy Busch. Last reply by Rose Ericson Jun 7. 7 Replies

Head stock

Started by Doug "Nomad" Farish. Last reply by John Sawyer Jun 4. 10 Replies

Second Build

Started by Doug "Nomad" Farish. Last reply by Doug "Nomad" Farish May 30. 3 Replies

Bridge Placement

Started by Doug "Nomad" Farish. Last reply by Doug "Nomad" Farish May 27. 5 Replies

Using zip ties for frets

Started by Andy Busch. Last reply by Forrest Johnson May 19. 1 Reply

Glues?

Started by rodger moore. Last reply by Uncle John May 17. 10 Replies

First Build

Started by Doug "Nomad" Farish. Last reply by Doug "Nomad" Farish May 15. 8 Replies

Asking for critiques ... first build

Started by Dirk. Last reply by Jeff 'Bones' Reilly May 14. 10 Replies

Ideal fret board hieght above box?

Started by rodger moore. Last reply by ChickenboneJohn May 13. 5 Replies

Fret Board

Started by Doug "Nomad" Farish. Last reply by Doug "Nomad" Farish May 13. 5 Replies

License plate top or wood?

Started by Michelle Ray. Last reply by James Matthews May 11. 4 Replies

A speaker I found in the trash

Started by Andy Busch. Last reply by John Sawyer May 10. 5 Replies

Fretboard overhangs

Started by Scott Godwin. Last reply by Order99 May 4. 3 Replies

Why taper the width of the neck?

Started by Rob Uker. Last reply by Keith Rearick Apr 18. 5 Replies

What to do with a silverware box?

Started by Andy Busch. Last reply by Paul Craig Apr 16. 15 Replies

Neck to Body offset

Started by Thomas Parr. Last reply by Thomas Parr Apr 6. 10 Replies

Sealed tuner question.

Started by Dirk. Last reply by Dirk Apr 5. 3 Replies

Latest Activity

Dave Lynas commented on Andries D. EKER's video
Thumbnail

MOJO BREW BCB Diddley (Electric) A.D.Eker 2018

"Way cool Andries. Your effects were wonderful. Great pickins!"
7 minutes ago
Dave Lynas liked Andries D. EKER's video
8 minutes ago
Dennis Reedy commented on Richard Sundberg's video
Thumbnail

Metronome Moments

"Super sound, love the open D.  Thanks for the nice comments  and pictures of the big…"
12 minutes ago
Dave Lynas commented on Steebos Kalist's video
Thumbnail

STEEBOS Original #1

"I like your sliding. Without shaking your bar you were in tune. Good play."
12 minutes ago
Dave Lynas liked Steebos Kalist's video
13 minutes ago
Dave Lynas liked c# merle's video
17 minutes ago
Dave Lynas commented on c# merle's video
Thumbnail

one little pill

"Love the animation. Great drawings. Good clear vocals and play. Thanks much."
17 minutes ago
the anonymous pick commented on Jim Morris's photo
Thumbnail

Drew Estates CB Fiddle

"the thrill of the chase is indeed a big part  ;-)"
22 minutes ago
Dave Lynas commented on Uncle John's video
Thumbnail

Sunday Gospel on a Home Made Banjo & Iowa Saxophone

"I like your guitar Uncle. Doesn’t sound very banjo esque. You need a proper skin head banjer…"
23 minutes ago
Jim Morris commented on Jim Morris's photo
Thumbnail

Drew Estates CB Fiddle

"Thanks for the info pick. I'll still look for them in journeys. It's simple enough to…"
26 minutes ago
Dave Lynas commented on Uncle John's video
Thumbnail

Sunday Gospel on a Home Made Banjo & Iowa Saxophone

"Bravo Uncle. The Velvet Hammer. Nice harping too. I got Mallard singing. Sound check later. "
30 minutes ago
Dave Lynas liked Uncle John's video
32 minutes ago

Music

Loading…

© 2018   Created by Ben "C. B. Gitty" Baker.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service