Hi all, my first post.

I have built  3-strign and  4 string CBG and I am beyond hooked.

So my question is about pickups.  How important is it to use a match string to pole.  My first CBG was with an old 6-poll humbuker and it seems work just fine.  But now that I have to buy some pickups I have a chance to be more specific.

And an extension to that question is what about the lipstick style. Those don't appear to specify polls.

BTW I have little technical knowledge about pickups, incase that is not already obvious.

And as long as you reading this if you have recommendation of pickups I would appreciate.  I want to keep thing as inexpensive as possible but I don't want to buy crap. 

Views: 474

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Two comments: the magnetic field over a six pole pickup is somewhat more complex than just six separate fields overneath each pole, you can experiment where the hot spots are using a distance holder and a piece of a string as a dowsing rod:

I don't have a free six pole pickup, so the setting is just to give an idea, but pickups with rails can be an alternative to n-pole pickups, cbgitty sells a «Pawn Shop Monorail Single-Coil» with an open rail, mini humbuckers like his «Snake Oil Mini Humbucker» too have rails underneath the cover. On the photo a 10K «Power Rail» from GFS, my preferred humbucker in the below 40 bucks range.

And you can always make a poor man's "rail" by placing a bit of flat bar steel across all the pole pieces...

But yeah, the mini-humbuckers are a good, relatively inexpensive choice. They dirty up nicely when cranked. Here's a vid of me playing a Swamp Witch fitted with one, cranked through a Crate V16 Palomino 15 watt tube amp:

http://www.cigarboxnation.com/video/oily-s-guitar-lounge-6-take-an-...

P.S. In a post which is lost, I did a similar test with a four pole single coil pickup with a plastic cover, searching for the hot spots 5mm above the cover: hottest spot was between the mid poles, second the end poles. So be prepared for surprises...

Lipstick Tube pickups have a single bar magnet inside wrapped with wire that extends throughout the whole pickup tube. As long as the tube is under the strings, they will work fine.

The thing to watch out for is having mis-matched spacing, where some stings are directly over a pole and some are between poles, you will get un-even output guaaaranteeed!.

either all strings over a pole, or all string between poles evenly, and it ought to be well inside the 'no rules' parameters LOL

on second thought, no rules, hmm...bass strings under a pole, treble strings off-spaced, might actually sound right good ... hmmm...

Thanks, that make a lot of sense.

So the Snake Oil Humbuker would eliminate the concern since it is a continuous bar.

Yes, the Snake Oil humbucker has two rails underneath the cover, I will post a photo in some hour.

Snake Oil humbucker top view:

Snake Oil humbucker bottom view

the cover is nonferrous

Moritz, I bought similar pickups from GFS That was supposed to be a Firebird type, but was more Mini-Humbucker like yours. They advertised that the cover was German Silver plated cover, but mine was just Chrome over Copper. Some pickup companies use Brass covers instead, but both of these type covers can have bad tone results because of their affects to the pickup's Eddy Currents.

The pickup I had wasn't bad, wasn't great. It definitely didn't have a Firebird tone. My plan is to buy a Firebird pickup kit from Stewmac and rebuild this pickup to be more like an original Firebird pickup. Will also get a cover that matches the original specs.

Anybody can take one of those pickups and change the magnet underneath to a better ceramic magnet, Alnico magnet or Neodymium magnet for better tone if they aren't satisfied with them. That also applies to the Strat or Tele type single coil pickups that are made in China that have a bar magnet across the bottom. The magnet change can make a big difference.

Paul, if I remove from a Snake Oil Humbucker the magnet underneath the pickup and replace the blades with Alnico magnets, do I get a Firebird type pickup? Sure, the result with 9.5K would be somewhat hotter as an original Firebird with about 7.0K. The blades measures are 2.10" x 0.55" x 0.12".

I think that the magnets in the Stewmac kit will fit, Got thesuggestion from someone on the TDPRI forum that has done this mod. Their are other pieces in the kit that aren't present in the mini-bucker pickup that I have and it doesn't appear to be in the Snake Oil pickup according to the pics you posted. Here is a link to the kit showing all the pieces.

http://www.stewmac.com/Pickups_and_Electronics/Pickup_Kits_and_Part...

As the blades protrude from underneath the pickup for the thickness of the ceramic magnet which holds the bobbins together, I have to correct the measures for a replacement: 2.10" x 0.43" x 0.12".

RSS

The Essential Pages

New to Cigar Box Nation?How to Play Cigar Box GuitarsFree Plans & How to Build Cigar Box GuitarsCigar Box Guitar Building BasicsCigar Box Guitar Parts Store

Site Sponsor

Recommended Links & Resources

Forum

Weird buzz as I turn volume knob

Started by Jerryrig240 in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Scavanged Sound (Pete) 4 hours ago. 2 Replies

2 unrelated questions

Started by Dustin Aurand in Cool gear discussion - that's not cigar box related. Last reply by Ron "Oily" Sprague 5 hours ago. 1 Reply

MYSTERY INSTRUMENT: What are these antique dulcimer things?

Started by Shane (www.ShaneSpeal.com) in Feature Articles. Last reply by Ron "Oily" Sprague 6 hours ago. 45 Replies

Building with Aspen?

Started by Hal Robertson in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Rose Ericson yesterday. 2 Replies

Artistic Lap Steels Made from 2x4's (Videos + Pics)

Started by Shane (www.ShaneSpeal.com) in Feature Articles. Last reply by Steve Tucker yesterday. 22 Replies

Odd vibration

Started by David Blackburn in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by David Blackburn on Saturday. 5 Replies

Songs inAm

Started by Dustin Aurand in Performances, How to Play, Lessons, Concerts. Last reply by Lane Martin on Thursday. 31 Replies

Latest Activity

John posted a video

Missouri Flood 2017 by John Seabaugh - Cigar Box Guitar Blues

I wrote and recorded this simple chorus today after driving around and looking at some of the flooding in the area. In case you didn't know, Missouri has bee...
32 minutes ago
Crowdaddy liked Nation News's discussion CONTEST! Paint Lid Challenge - Submit here!!! Ends April 30, 2017
1 hour ago
Crowdaddy posted photos
1 hour ago
Sharon Litwak posted a video

Diddley Bow Fun

I ordered a Deadly Bow from Shane Speal and it sounds awesome! Thanks Shane. I filmed the arrival with my GoPro and did my first video edit with Adobe Premie...
1 hour ago
Gary Wiese commented on Tom Talarico's photo
Thumbnail

new dulcimer 004

"Love it. Great design and craftmanship."
2 hours ago
Crowdaddy replied to Nation News's discussion CONTEST! Paint Lid Challenge - Submit here!!! Ends April 30, 2017
"The body is a spanish cedar cigar box.I removed the bottom and replaced it with a piece of book…"
2 hours ago
John Rivers commented on ChickenboneJohn's photo
Thumbnail

New guitar with Lace Alumitone pickup

"John your madness has no borders."
2 hours ago
JD Moor replied to Nation News's discussion CONTEST! Paint Lid Challenge - Submit here!!! Ends April 30, 2017
"That is fantastic, looks incredible"
3 hours ago
Blind Lemon Cello commented on Blind Lemon Cello's photo
3 hours ago
Wade replied to Nation News's discussion CONTEST! Paint Lid Challenge - Submit here!!! Ends April 30, 2017
"Thanks Darryl!"
3 hours ago
darryl kernaghan replied to Nation News's discussion CONTEST! Paint Lid Challenge - Submit here!!! Ends April 30, 2017
"Great homemade effort Wade, ticks all the boxes for me"
3 hours ago
Wade posted photos
3 hours ago

Music

Loading…

© 2017   Created by Ben "C. B. Gitty" Baker.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service