So I joined another web site all about dulcimers, I really just did it to get a set of plans I wanted. Anyway, I post a question about how small a dulcimer do you all make. I had made one using just a single cigar box so it was pretty small it had 2 strings and it has a sweet sound. The only response I get is some clown telling me I can't really call it a dulcimer if it does not have 3-4 strings because I can't even chord along with 2. I did not even answer although there are many answers worth giving from yes I can chord along to asking him about Galax style playing. The thing is, I do not want to be in any box. No rules opens up a lot of new ideas. So thanks to Shane for doing away with all that BS way back in the beginning. Has this happened to any of you all?

Views: 377

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Yep. Happens on mandolin, banjo, ukelele and other stringed instrument sites all the time. It even happens here fairly often. But at least here, when it does, a chorus of voices, including mine, shouts "No Rulz!" Then we go on to yell at the poor soul about there being actual guidelines if they wanna get proper intonation. ;-)

Nothing wrong with like minded folks having their own group.

Exactly right Gus. Good to have both types of groups. If I wanted to learn how to make an authentic, traditional style instrument, thats the place I'd look. Nothing wrong with that at all. Trouble is, some or them come off as being exclusive and snooty when asked a question like this.

Oh ya. Not just on forums but face to face. I'm into steampunk. It's a fandom with so many conflicting rules there's no real set to go by. But someone will always let you know when your breaking one of their personal mantras.  These people are collectively known as "Prop Nazis". They exist in all fandoms. But steampunk seems to bring them to an annoying point. Take it way to seriously. 

It has to work.

It has to be made of real materials. Leather, metal and wood.

Be an exact replica of something from the mid 1800's.  bla bla bla bla.

I tell them,

" The day someone floats here in a cast iron, steam powered air ship is the day I'll stop using cardboard."

but the Victorians were heavy into paper mache . i think i remember some lacquered PM boxes on antiques roadshow... and those guys didnt turn their noses up at it...lol

 

I have gotten some wierd looks from so called aficionados. I have gotten to the point of not carrying what they say or how they precieve what I do. And I love galax dulcimers they really show how ingenious dulcimer makers were to amp up the sound of their creations!

Yup Matt, for me it's usually "your cigar box fiddle sounds pretty good....you ought to try making a real one"

Here's what I think of rules...

just exactly how I felt. I play by my own rules, I take no prisoners I do no harm I hum the national anthem at ballgames but will share my bathroom with anyone. I build the cigarbox guitar with peace love and understanding and I will accept any instrument in any way you want as long as you can shred it in a way I feel deep into my ball sac. Amen!

Cigar box nation home of musical anarachism :-)
Yeah, I get the side eye and "you should build a regular guitar" sometimes, but whatever. One thing I've come to respect though are the folks who are very serious about keeping the traditional ways alive. I think there's room for both and we need them both.

I've gotten the 'look down at' from other musicians. I tell them,

"Anyone can make six strings sound good. Try using three." 

And then there's the modern tuning purists. Hypocrites. They claim there is only one tuning for a guitar. Then detune their guitars to match The Rolling Stones, Neil Young, and so on and so on.... : )

Music has never been about the instrument. It's about self expression and art.  

RSS

The Essential Pages

New to Cigar Box Nation?How to Play Cigar Box GuitarsFree Plans & How to Build Cigar Box GuitarsCigar Box Guitar Building BasicsCigar Box Guitar Parts Store

Site Sponsor

Recommended Links & Resources

Forum

Sun Studio Sessions

Started by Paul Craig in Other stuff - off topic, fun stuff, whatever. Last reply by Paul Craig 11 minutes ago. 1 Reply

Painted instruments

Started by Dustin Aurand in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Titch the Clown 36 minutes ago. 7 Replies

Homemade Pickup...

Started by Brian Revels in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Paul Craig 39 minutes ago. 17 Replies

Newbie builder woes :(

Started by John Michael Ames in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by John Michael Ames 2 hours ago. 2 Replies

Lots of questions

Started by Jeremiah Peed in Performances, How to Play, Lessons, Concerts. Last reply by Jim Morris 3 hours ago. 6 Replies

Songs inAm

Started by Dustin Aurand in Performances, How to Play, Lessons, Concerts. Last reply by Jim Morris 3 hours ago. 14 Replies

Hymn For Her debuts new video: "Milkweed"

Started by Shane (www.ShaneSpeal.com) in Feature Articles 5 hours ago. 0 Replies

Gig Bags

Started by Phil Gershwiin in Performances, How to Play, Lessons, Concerts. Last reply by Snuffy Smith yesterday. 18 Replies

Latest Activity

Ted Stahl replied to Nation News's discussion CONTEST! Paint Lid Challenge - Submit here!!! Ends April 30, 2017
"This is my #10:THE HOT ROD. Just like a hot rod, it's stripped down and simple.It has an oak…"
46 seconds ago
David Bowes joined BeetleJuice!'s group
Thumbnail

Old Radio Guitar Amps

This is the group for Lo-Watt Rock & Blues.Here is the place to post photos and information on…See More
57 seconds ago
Scott Schoepf commented on sparky37's photo
Thumbnail

1776 fan fret flag guitar

"What Ron said, that's gorgeous!"
4 minutes ago
Paul Craig commented on wes carl's blog post Uncle John Oh my aching back
"Yeah it can get you so uncomfortable sometimes that no position feels good. A soak in a tub of hot…"
5 minutes ago
Scott Schoepf liked sparky37's photo
6 minutes ago
Paul Craig replied to Paul Craig's discussion Sun Studio Sessions
"They played 3 songs and this video is of the last song where the singer played lead on his LP.…"
11 minutes ago
Uncle John commented on Dave Lynas's video
Thumbnail

Little Darlin Pal of mine

"just what the doctor ordered!"
14 minutes ago
the anonymous pick commented on Daniel Hulbert's photo
Thumbnail

Walking Stick One String Bass and siblings

"I lean towards  supporting you  in your  leg up on the competition . ;-)"
17 minutes ago
Uncle John commented on wes carl's blog post Uncle John Oh my aching back
"that sucks, Paul.  I had NO conception of how bad back and nerve pain can be.   Ironic,…"
18 minutes ago
Paul Craig posted a discussion

Sun Studio Sessions

My local PBS station has this show on every weekend and has had some great acts on. This weekend…See More
20 minutes ago
Andries D. EKER posted photos
21 minutes ago
Ted Stahl liked Shane (www.ShaneSpeal.com)'s video
27 minutes ago

Music

Loading…

© 2017   Created by Ben "C. B. Gitty" Baker.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service