I know this has been covered somewhere, but can't find exactly what I am looking for.  I am a newbie maker.  I am currently making a 4-string CBG from a Tabak wooden box.  I am doing a neck-thru and wanting to mix a piezo buzzer with a homemade pickup I made.

The pickup I made is basically two very strong hard-drive magnets wrapped in copper wire (about 600 wraps or so), then placed into a steel Altoids tin I modified to look like a mini-humbucker (will take a pic and post as soon as I can if needed). I don't have any pole pieces in that I was looking for the top of the Altoids tin (bottom depending on your perspective) to be magnetized and act as one flat "pole piece".

I wired it to an input jack, plugged it in to a small Crate amp, and hung it inside an acoustic guitar to try seeing what it would pickup on.  It didn't seem to work.  So I am wondering if I HAVE to have pole pieces and if I need to redesign my pickup?

My biggest fear is cutting a slot for the pickup in my lid, wiring it up, and then it not work. I'd have to scrap the box then since my single-coil "mini-bucker" and an actual pickup I have from an old Fender are totally different sizes.

Any help would be much appreciated!

Views: 1151

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

hanging a magnetic pickup inside an accoustic guitar wont give you any sound, it nees to be close to a steel string as its the steel moving that moves the magnetic field in the pickup making the current to be amplified, try holding it above the strings of an electric guitar first.

Hey Brian - I have been fiddling with various pickups myself, winding some, using existing windings, wall warts, cordless drill charging units etc.

It would be nice if there was a "sticky" at the top on this topic, just for use newbs.
I have made a simple one string dealy with about a 3" hole and a jack mounted with little alligator clips just to try different pickup before I commit to installing them. I aim for about 1/4" below the strings for my tests, you may not be close enough.

What OFG said....make sure you are not trying to test using bronze strings.

*these still have a steel core and so ought produce some current. I think a shorted/broken coil more likely. Does it produce a click when you tap it with a screwdriver or key? Can you check the coils continuity/resistance with a multimeter. Everyone needs to rewind their first pickup a time or two...

No sound at all... I had a buddy help me with a multimeter and it seems the coil, and/or soldered connections, may have been grounding on the tin box. I have now insulated the box with some thin rubber and going to try it out again (multimeter first and then amp tonight maybe).  These magnets are super strong and should still keep the outside tin magnetized, even through the rubber.

So it sounds like my theory is solid, and I don't need pole pieces, just need to keep fiddling with it.  Please correct me if I am wrong with that thinking.

you shouldn't need pole pieces, I've made a couple just out of ring magnets and they worked fine. what I was saying is it needs to be close to the strings, don't just dangle it inside the guitar as that won't work. I've never tried one with only 600 turns though, might not get much out of that (usually at least 2000) Also although the pickup needs to be close to the strings a neodymium magnet has a huge magnetic field and will dampen the strings vibrations if put too close. Might have to do a bit of huntin to find the sweet spot.

you may have figured all of this out all ready, but sometimes when winding your own stuff, you need magnetic wire, the wax coated wire used for coils and pick ups. If you are winding it around steel or something, and it that wax coating gets cut and is touching something metal, or the coil is touching two bares wires inside the coil, then it will be a dead pick up.  Just to be on the safe side.  I am experienting with some stuff here latley, and I cut a piece of metal for a flat style pup and the edges are really sharp.  It's a good idea to keep in mind when winding stuff.

http://i950.photobucket.com/albums/ad348/jeflong/2012%2005%20woody8...

You shouldn't need pole pieces, click on link there, I've done exactly the same before and they work great. However the big sheet of steel is said to affect to magnetic field which is why telecaster neck pup etc is covered in a non ferrous cover. Try snapping another magnet on the outside (top) before you cut open the coil to see if it helps like this

http://i950.photobucket.com/albums/ad348/jeflong/2012%2009%20MagicR...

However if failing a continuity test you might need to rewind. Can you get the coil out of the tin, wrap it in tape and put it back?

Here's a pic of what I did.  If you have ever seen a hard drive magnet inside a hard drive then you recognize the shape of the back-plate.  I left one magnet attached to it, removed the plate from the other magnet and just snapped it ontop of the other.  I then wrapped it up with 30 gauge copper wire.  The steel case is part of an Altoids box and is insulated with part of a rubber glove.

I got some connectivity tonight, but only along the bottom side of the box, not the top.  I pulled it out of the box only to realize that the corners (right next to where it is wired to the input jack) are the only spots I get a signal.  It's not doing ANYTHING anywhere else.  Those points touch the bottom of the box when seated so it gets a signal (in that I can tap on it with my fingers or a piece of metal).  There is still NO sound. :-(

The magnet needs to be in contact with the strings on this one.  The magnets need to be bare.  So the wire needs to be around the magnet.  Like a typical pickup.  And I am not sure what wire you are using there, but it needs to be coating. Just old copper wire will not work. Hope this helps. One of the best and easiest pickups you can build with is a sewing bobbin pickup. Wind up a bobbin with wire and use a bolt through it and add a magnet to the bottom. Perfect for one string builds.

You pickup design sounds like a Lipstick Tube style pickup. My guesses are: 1-you could have a break in the coil winding. 2-your coil is shorting out inside the case. 3-your coil isn't strong enough and needs more windings.

It's possible the wire is wound around the coil the wrong way for it to work lengthwise.

Here is somebody who made a working hard drive magnet pickup: http://www.joebrown.org.uk/wp/?p=1476

This is the same direction/orientation the lipstick tube coil was wound. 

The question is, was a lipstick tube magnet oriented through the width or the length? I always assumed it was through the width. Whereas the hard drive magnet appears to be oriented through the length, like a science bar magnet. 

You may be able to take your pickup as is, and turn it on end and have it work. So it would be like one giant polepiece from a Strat pickup. 

On the other hand, it could be that those "rules" about magnet orientation are for weaker alnico and ceramic magnets and it wouldn't matter which way you oriented a hard drive magnet. I don't have any here to play with, so I can't say for sure. 

In general, I suggest getting the pickup working without the cover first, then add the cover and see what happens. You can quickly test the pickup by holding it closely over the strings and plucking the strings. 

RSS

The Essential Pages

New to Cigar Box Nation?How to Play Cigar Box GuitarsFree Plans & How to Build Cigar Box GuitarsCigar Box Guitar Building BasicsCigar Box Guitar Parts Store

Site Sponsor

Recommended Links & Resources

Forum

Folk Outsider, 3-String Stephen LIVE at Gitty's

Started by Shane Speal shanespeal.com in Feature Articles. Last reply by jeff Cadzow 14 hours ago. 2 Replies

Thin a top

Started by Mark Werner in Building Secrets, Tips, Advice, Discussion. Last reply by Paul Craig yesterday. 21 Replies

Threw the PICK away

Started by Jeff 'Bones' Reilly in Performances, How to Play, Lessons, Concerts. Last reply by Dustin Aurand on Monday. 9 Replies

Blade Runner Blues on CBG

Started by Dustin Aurand in Performances, How to Play, Lessons, Concerts. Last reply by Cause the Blue rat on Sunday. 9 Replies

2017 Plumber's Challenge Winners

Started by Shane Speal shanespeal.com in Feature Articles. Last reply by Paul Craig on Saturday. 14 Replies

Latest Activity

Grandpa posted a discussion

Turkey Roasting Pan Git

Recently finished my roasting pan git. Birch ply top, red oak neck and fretboard. Bone nut and…See More
23 minutes ago
Cause the Blue rat replied to Shane Speal shanespeal.com's discussion The Good, The Bad & The Ugly on Cigar Box Guitar! Latest viral video from Jerome Graille
"Hey Blondy. There are three types of people in this world. Those who only need three strings. And…"
1 hour ago
Bob Harrison posted a photo

Harrison cigar box guitar pickups

My prototype cigar box guitar pickup in the 1930's Americana folk art style..It will have a change…
2 hours ago
Anthony Insetta posted a video

Sweet strat of mine !!! LOL

via YouTube Capture
2 hours ago
the anonymous pick commented on Dar Stellabotta's video
Thumbnail

One Day on Diddley Bow

"one day  , one girl , one string  , one thousand inspired . ;-)"
2 hours ago
the anonymous pick commented on the anonymous pick's video
Thumbnail

NEW line from swamp witch guitars

"check yer mail  Kev . "
2 hours ago
Ted Stahl replied to Ted Stahl's discussion Taking CBG's to a festival
"Thanks Grandpa (that sounds weird seeing I'm 63). But the advice you gave is just what I…"
2 hours ago
Jon Clemence posted a video

Ashton Cigar Box Guitar Demo

This video demos a 3-string slide guitar that I made from an Ashton brand cigar box. The neck is oak with an ebony fretboard. The "frets" are wood-burned lin...
2 hours ago
Erasmo Coco commented on AGP #'s photo
Thumbnail

AGP #291 - ''El Rey''

"Very nice !  Great neck ."
2 hours ago
Erasmo Coco liked AGP #'s photo
2 hours ago
Dar Stellabotta posted a video
2 hours ago
Dar Stellabotta commented on Dar Stellabotta's video
Thumbnail

One Day on Diddley Bow

"Thank you everyone <3"
2 hours ago

Music

Loading…

© 2017   Created by Ben "C. B. Gitty" Baker.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service